3 San Antonio Restaurants Named Among Yelp’s Top Sandwich Shops in the U.S.

by Tre Serrano

Which San Antonio sandwich shops made it onto Yelp’s list of the best in America?

San Antonio’s food scene continues to shine on the national stage, and this time it’s all about sandwiches. According to Yelp’s new list of the Top 100 Sandwich Shops in the United States, three San Antonio eateries earned coveted spots thanks to rave reviews, creative menus, and loyal fanbases: Gino’s Deli Stop N Buy, PB&J with Tay, and Bilia Eatery.

How Yelp Chose the Best

Yelp’s list was shaped by the number of reviews, overall star ratings, and sandwich-specific qualities such as:

Portability
Affordability
Popularity
Visual appeal
Sauces and toppings
Bread quality

With thousands of reviewers weighing in, only 100 shops across the country made the cut — and San Antonio secured three of them.

Gino’s Deli Stop N Buy – No. 9 in the Nation

Leading the local pack is Gino’s Deli Stop N Buy, a Northwest Side institution that landed at No. 9 nationally. Owned by Aleem Chaudhry, Gino’s is already a familiar name on “best of” lists. It’s been recognized by the San Antonio Current’s readers, Yelp’s Top 100 U.S. Restaurants for 2024, and even national outlets praising its cheesesteaks.

Famous dishes: The Philly cheesesteak is legendary, but regulars also rave about the “Smoke Stack” (smoked turkey, bacon, provolone, chipotle aioli) and the loaded club sandwich stacked with roast beef, ham, turkey, jalapeños, lettuce, and mayo.
Why fans love it: Beyond the food, reviewers say the service makes every visit feel like “catching up with an old friend.” That welcoming vibe has built one of San Antonio’s most loyal followings.

PB&J with Tay – A Playful Twist on a Classic

At PB&J with Tay, the humble peanut butter and jelly sandwich gets a gourmet makeover. Opened in 2019 by Jessica Burns, it’s the only restaurant in Texas dedicated to PB&J, and Yelp reviewers can’t stop talking about it.

Creative flavors: Bacon, banana, Nutella, walnuts, and other inventive toppings elevate this childhood staple into a fun and filling meal.
Dining experience: Customers describe it as quirky, cute, and memorable — perfect for a casual lunch or even a unique date.

Bilia Eatery – Latin Flair in Castle Hills

The third San Antonio standout is Bilia Eatery, run by chefs Bryan Rojas and Mariana Wong in Castle Hills. Their menu reflects a mix of Cuban and Latin influences that keep regulars coming back for more.

Signature dishes: The Cuban sandwich is a must-try, alongside seasonal soups, arepas, salads, and their famous barbacoa melt.
Reviewer favorites: Many call it “one of the most underrated spots in all of San Antonio,” citing the fresh flavors, friendly service, and cozy atmosphere.

Why This Recognition Matters

National recognition on platforms like Yelp brings new attention — and new visitors — to San Antonio’s local food scene. These three restaurants demonstrate the city’s diversity and creativity when it comes to dining, offering something for everyone:

A beloved deli with legendary cheesesteaks
A playful café that reinvents a childhood classic
A Latin-inspired eatery bringing bold flavors to the table

The Takeaway

San Antonio isn’t just making great sandwiches — it’s making a national statement. With three eateries ranked among the country’s top 100, the city continues to prove its culinary scene is as creative and inviting as anywhere else in the U.S. Next time you’re craving a sandwich, you don’t need to look far — some of the best in America are right here in San Antonio.

📬 Brought to you by CallTheCavalryGroup.com — Serving up the best of San Antonio’s food, lifestyle, and local insights.